{
 "artifact_type": "BOUNDED_EVIDENCE_PREVIEW",
 "preview_boundary": "Deliberately bounded representative records for demonstration. Not a complete claim, evidence, study, or provenance inventory.",
 "food": "Black Cohosh",
 "slug": "black-cohosh",
 "dataset_id": "MFI-BLACOH-20261023-FS",
 "engine_version": "2.0-R13",
 "package_sha256_prefix": "1d14cbe8e6359439",
 "claims": [
  {
   "claim_id": "CLM-4e4e0ba999d4d01f",
   "object": "black cohosh constituents",
   "outcome": "liver",
   "direction": "HARM",
   "grade": "VERY_LOW",
   "design": [
    "ANIMAL",
    "META_ANALYSIS"
   ],
   "models": [
    "ANIMAL",
    "HUMAN"
   ],
   "dose": "1000 mg/kg",
   "duration": "90 days",
   "grade_basis": {
    "bound_studies": 5,
    "confidence_cap": "LOW",
    "consistency_cap": "HIGH",
    "design_ceiling": "HIGH",
    "directness_cap": "LOW",
    "extraction_cap": "LOW",
    "numeric_cap": "MODERATE",
    "numeric_states": [
     "NO_NUMERICS_PRESENT",
     "VALIDATED_EXTRACTION"
    ],
    "opposition_adj": "downgraded_one_step_for_bound_opposition",
    "quantitative_observations": 6,
    "rob_cap": "MODERATE",
    "rob_worst_judgment": "INSUFFICIENT_INFORMATION"
   },
   "bound_studies": [
    {
     "study_id": "STU-063d1688ebbee2d8",
     "design": "META_ANALYSIS",
     "model": "HUMAN",
     "publication_year": 2011,
     "dose": null,
     "duration": null,
     "extraction_status": "UNASSESSED",
     "full_text_status": "FULL_TEXT",
     "endpoint_directions": {
      "liver": "HARM"
     },
     "risk_of_bias": "INSUFFICIENT_INFORMATION",
     "provenance_refs": [
      "epmc:21228727"
     ]
    },
    {
     "study_id": "STU-1142b332f60c28e8",
     "design": "ANIMAL",
     "model": "ANIMAL",
     "publication_year": 2012,
     "dose": "1000 mg/kg",
     "duration": "90 days",
     "extraction_status": "UNASSESSED",
     "full_text_status": "FULL_TEXT",
     "endpoint_directions": {
      "iron status": "BENEFIT",
      "liver": "HARM"
     },
     "risk_of_bias": "INSUFFICIENT_INFORMATION",
     "provenance_refs": [
      "epmc:22687605"
     ]
    },
    {
     "study_id": "STU-8c12c20cceb8f920",
     "design": "ANIMAL",
     "model": "ANIMAL",
     "publication_year": 2022,
     "dose": null,
     "duration": null,
     "extraction_status": "UNASSESSED",
     "full_text_status": "FULL_TEXT",
     "endpoint_directions": {
      "cancer": "HARM",
      "iron status": "HARM",
      "liver": "HARM"
     },
     "risk_of_bias": "INSUFFICIENT_INFORMATION",
     "provenance_refs": [
      "epmc:36373576"
     ]
    },
    {
     "study_id": "STU-b5ca87b107be0bac",
     "design": "META_ANALYSIS",
     "model": "HUMAN",
     "publication_year": 2011,
     "dose": null,
     "duration": null,
     "extraction_status": "UNASSESSED",
     "full_text_status": "ABSTRACT_ONLY",
     "endpoint_directions": {
      "liver": "HARM"
     },
     "risk_of_bias": "INSUFFICIENT_INFORMATION",
     "provenance_refs": [
      "oax:https://openalex.org/W2329547419"
     ]
    }
   ],
   "quantitative_observations": [
    {
     "observation_id": "QOB-11667e842b7dcd",
     "observation_kind": "p_value",
     "effect_measure": "p-value",
     "original_value": "0.37",
     "original_representation": "p=0.37",
     "original_unit": null,
     "normalized_value": 0.37,
     "normalized_unit": null,
     "endpoint": null,
     "extraction_state": "VALIDATED",
     "validation_state": "VALID",
     "transformation": "IDENTITY",
     "record_id": "oax:https://openalex.org/W2329547419"
    },
    {
     "observation_id": "QOB-18dc04ab14a590",
     "observation_kind": "n",
     "effect_measure": "sample size",
     "original_value": 517,
     "original_representation": "517",
     "original_unit": null,
     "normalized_value": 517.0,
     "normalized_unit": null,
     "endpoint": null,
     "extraction_state": "VALIDATED",
     "validation_state": "VALID",
     "transformation": "IDENTITY",
     "record_id": "oax:https://openalex.org/W2329547419"
    },
    {
     "observation_id": "QOB-a416d2581ca9eb",
     "observation_kind": "duration",
     "effect_measure": "duration",
     "original_value": null,
     "original_representation": "90 days",
     "original_unit": null,
     "normalized_value": null,
     "normalized_unit": null,
     "endpoint": null,
     "extraction_state": "FAILED_EXTRACTION",
     "validation_state": "FAILED_VALIDATION",
     "transformation": "NONE",
     "record_id": "epmc:22687605"
    },
    {
     "observation_id": "QOB-bef9217e132907",
     "observation_kind": "n",
     "effect_measure": "sample size",
     "original_value": 517,
     "original_representation": "517",
     "original_unit": null,
     "normalized_value": 517.0,
     "normalized_unit": null,
     "endpoint": null,
     "extraction_state": "VALIDATED",
     "validation_state": "VALID",
     "transformation": "IDENTITY",
     "record_id": "epmc:21228727"
    },
    {
     "observation_id": "QOB-e675951fadd0d3",
     "observation_kind": "p_value",
     "effect_measure": "p-value",
     "original_value": "0.37",
     "original_representation": "p=0.37",
     "original_unit": null,
     "normalized_value": 0.37,
     "normalized_unit": null,
     "endpoint": null,
     "extraction_state": "VALIDATED",
     "validation_state": "VALID",
     "transformation": "IDENTITY",
     "record_id": "epmc:21228727"
    }
   ],
   "opposition": {
    "considered": 8,
    "bound": 2
   },
   "synthesis": {
    "synthesis_id": "SYN-c03cb37fc1db03",
    "synthesis_outcome": "QUALITATIVE_ONLY",
    "direction_tally": {
     "HARM": 5
    },
    "directional_disagreement": false,
    "heterogeneity": "not_assessed_quantitatively",
    "study_members": [
     "STU-063d1688ebbee2d8",
     "STU-1142b332f60c28e8",
     "STU-8c12c20cceb8f920",
     "STU-b5ca87b107be0bac",
     "STU-c8aad32020b2b960"
    ],
    "observations_pooled": 0
   }
  },
  {
   "claim_id": "CLM-c700b713bf8d4fd1",
   "object": "black cohosh constituents",
   "outcome": "mood",
   "direction": "BENEFIT",
   "grade": "LOW",
   "design": [
    "ANIMAL",
    "META_ANALYSIS",
    "RCT"
   ],
   "models": [
    "ANIMAL",
    "HUMAN"
   ],
   "dose": "UNSPECIFIED",
   "duration": "UNSPECIFIED",
   "grade_basis": {
    "bound_studies": 3,
    "confidence_cap": "LOW",
    "consistency_cap": "MODERATE",
    "design_ceiling": "HIGH",
    "directness_cap": "LOW",
    "extraction_cap": "MODERATE",
    "numeric_cap": "MODERATE",
    "numeric_states": [
     "NO_NUMERICS_PRESENT",
     "VALIDATED_EXTRACTION"
    ],
    "opposition_adj": "none",
    "quantitative_observations": 6,
    "rob_cap": "MODERATE",
    "rob_worst_judgment": "INSUFFICIENT_INFORMATION"
   },
   "bound_studies": [
    {
     "study_id": "STU-320054bc4a19c76c",
     "design": "RCT",
     "model": "HUMAN",
     "publication_year": 2009,
     "dose": null,
     "duration": null,
     "extraction_status": "UNASSESSED",
     "full_text_status": "FULL_TEXT",
     "endpoint_directions": {
      "mood": "BENEFIT"
     },
     "risk_of_bias": "SOME_CONCERNS",
     "provenance_refs": [
      "epmc:19745648"
     ]
    },
    {
     "study_id": "STU-d51117b3324bc1d5",
     "design": "ANIMAL",
     "model": "ANIMAL",
     "publication_year": 2006,
     "dose": null,
     "duration": null,
     "extraction_status": "UNASSESSED",
     "full_text_status": "FULL_TEXT",
     "endpoint_directions": {
      "mood": "BENEFIT"
     },
     "risk_of_bias": "INSUFFICIENT_INFORMATION",
     "provenance_refs": [
      "epmc:17177511"
     ]
    },
    {
     "study_id": "STU-daea5913a221a05f",
     "design": "META_ANALYSIS",
     "model": "HUMAN",
     "publication_year": 2023,
     "dose": null,
     "duration": null,
     "extraction_status": "UNASSESSED",
     "full_text_status": "FULL_TEXT",
     "endpoint_directions": {
      "mood": "BENEFIT"
     },
     "risk_of_bias": "INSUFFICIENT_INFORMATION",
     "provenance_refs": [
      "epmc:37192826"
     ]
    }
   ],
   "quantitative_observations": [
    {
     "observation_id": "QOB-10e302ddda626d",
     "observation_kind": "n",
     "effect_measure": "sample size",
     "original_value": 15,
     "original_representation": "15",
     "original_unit": null,
     "normalized_value": 15.0,
     "normalized_unit": null,
     "endpoint": null,
     "extraction_state": "VALIDATED",
     "validation_state": "VALID",
     "transformation": "IDENTITY",
     "record_id": "epmc:19745648"
    },
    {
     "observation_id": "QOB-27f58907a03ff6",
     "observation_kind": "effect",
     "effect_measure": null,
     "original_value": null,
     "original_representation": "p = 0.294 | p = 0.79",
     "original_unit": null,
     "normalized_value": null,
     "normalized_unit": null,
     "endpoint": null,
     "extraction_state": "FAILED_EXTRACTION",
     "validation_state": "FAILED_VALIDATION",
     "transformation": "NONE",
     "record_id": "epmc:19745648"
    },
    {
     "observation_id": "QOB-832184a8692207",
     "observation_kind": "n",
     "effect_measure": "sample size",
     "original_value": 310,
     "original_representation": "310",
     "original_unit": null,
     "normalized_value": 310.0,
     "normalized_unit": null,
     "endpoint": null,
     "extraction_state": "VALIDATED",
     "validation_state": "VALID",
     "transformation": "IDENTITY",
     "record_id": "epmc:37192826"
    },
    {
     "observation_id": "QOB-b57790fd807ad3",
     "observation_kind": "p_value",
     "effect_measure": "p-value",
     "original_value": "0.035",
     "original_representation": "p = 0.035",
     "original_unit": null,
     "normalized_value": 0.035,
     "normalized_unit": null,
     "endpoint": null,
     "extraction_state": "VALIDATED",
     "validation_state": "VALID",
     "transformation": "IDENTITY",
     "record_id": "epmc:19745648"
    },
    {
     "observation_id": "QOB-b671143cee3f55",
     "observation_kind": "p_value",
     "effect_measure": "p-value",
     "original_value": "0.001",
     "original_representation": "p < 0.001",
     "original_unit": null,
     "normalized_value": 0.001,
     "normalized_unit": null,
     "endpoint": null,
     "extraction_state": "VALIDATED",
     "validation_state": "VALID",
     "transformation": "IDENTITY",
     "record_id": "epmc:37192826"
    }
   ],
   "opposition": {
    "considered": 4,
    "bound": 0
   },
   "synthesis": {
    "synthesis_id": "SYN-d1a57a2221646a",
    "synthesis_outcome": "QUALITATIVE_ONLY",
    "direction_tally": {
     "BENEFIT": 3
    },
    "directional_disagreement": false,
    "heterogeneity": "not_assessed_quantitatively",
    "study_members": [
     "STU-320054bc4a19c76c",
     "STU-d51117b3324bc1d5",
     "STU-daea5913a221a05f"
    ],
    "observations_pooled": 0
   }
  }
 ]
}